Classic puzzle, new approach or just a “two kinds of people” moment?

VagabondShad · 2Y

some_guy · 2Y

Yeah so the real full setup is that both of the guards can lie exactly once and only when asked the proper question to elicit their lie.

CileTheSane · 2Y

Yes, the exact same thing said by the person you accused of changing the rules on a whim.

some_guy · 2Y

No with his setup there’s different rules. My rules are the real ones

CileTheSane · 2Y

The “real” ones. I guess those are the rules “real” guards use in real life?

It’s a riddle. The rules are whatever suits the riddle being presented.